How can Brook White still be on AI when she has twice forgotten her lyrics and MJ is on the side line. If I have to look at her 12 yr old pouting face when she goes b4 the judges again I'm gonna "take the exhaust pipe" I was so much looking forward to hearing MJ sing twice when they get to the final four but I guess that was wishjful thinking wasn't it

Still pissed at the whole damn thing Even more so then when Chris D got booted because I think MJ has a more pure sound and a very diverse voice

Ok I'm done ranting sorry

Normally forgetting the lyrics is a death sentence,Brook must have a huge fan base,and that may be what has carried her through ! I think it has become more of a popularity contest than a singing compitition. If it were purely for the singing Michael would have been the last one standing !

^^ American Idol has long been a popularity contest instead of a singing one. I've learned that a long time ago. It seems to be what happens.

I think Brooke was saved this week simply because her fans got nervous because of her messing up. Her fan base is bigger than Carly's which is why Carly slipped away this week. It's a shame, I would have actually rather saw Syesha go than either of the girls but since it's not happening oh well. I've lost interest in the show since Michael left, I just don't really care for anyone thats left.

[quote name='xxmissxx' date='Apr 24 2008, 07:59 PM' post='2124']
^^ American Idol has long been a popularity contest instead of a singing one. I've learned that a long time ago. It seems to be what happens.

I think Brooke was saved this week simply because her fans got nervous because of her messing up. Her fan base is bigger than Carly's which is why Carly slipped away this week. It's a shame, I would have actually rather saw Syesha go than either of the girls but since it's not happening oh well. I've lost interest in the show since Michael left, I just don't really care for anyone thats left.
[/quote/]

100% right....and i really don't care who's going home, actually i don't watch A.I now! I'll watch it if Ryan will say,"I'm sorry america, but american idol is permanently close",................THAT WOULD BE THE HAPPIEST GIFT FOR MY BIRTHDAY LAST FRIDAY!(APRIL 25). My birthday super sucks! First. Michael was eliminated, Second. My favorite animal named Flower died...(crying)...I'll put this year and day to my diary to be the worst year of all!

^^ aww, I'm sorry about your animal.

But Happy Birthday! Even though it's late....

Thank you very much Even though....My favorite animal meerkat in TV died and his name was REN!!!! NOOOOO!!! What did i do to make ths year awful?????