Idol gives back then Eliminated? What happen if next week's show.................................................................

Ryan said "Fox heard you America, we love & care about you so heeeeereeees MICHAEL JOHNS! HE IS STILL A CONTENDER!"

See...some facts hits me..one them is when Ryan said that last year noone was voted off...I smell something weird...

Here's the facts:
http://www.americanidol.com/myidol/forums/topic/?tid=890156

I've been skimming through the posts there, & a lot of them do make some valuable points.

Maybe AI was doing this to get a rise out of fans, seeing as he does have a HUGE fan base.
I don't see HOW he had the lowest number of votes since people have said they had a hard time getting through to even vote for him, including me for quite some time.

But however, I don't want to get my hopes up either, because then it'll be a huge let down if it's not true.

Yeah..but there's nothing to lose if we try......

I don't want to get my hopes up either but if he comes back I'll probably cry. (Happy tears of course!)

Aww... what happend fanmates? I'm 13 and i will never-ever lose hope..if it isn't I'm proud of myself coz I'm brave of trying it...A DARE DEVIL? I cried 4 hours and stopped when i saw something fishy....a thought just pop in my head and said that crying doesn't make sense..what if... I rather support him and try it?

I think I'd lose my sanity if I got my hopes up & it was crushed haha.
No, seriously.

I know what you mean, I'm not giving up hope that it COULD very well be true, because there are good facts stated there.
I don't see HOW they could just ship someone off, especially at this part of the AI with the IGB. It just seems inhumane & sh*tty.
They make it a point of "oh we didn't send anyone home last season, but this time, see ya later!", type crap. It's a little low.

I'm confused, but I'm scared to get those hopes up again. Everyone seemed pretty authentically shocked for this to be rigged.

Ha ha ha..My heart broked! It's business..and money....I knew many scams and cheats in shows coz my father is a chef of High People and highly position...... My father knew many confedential secrets and he knew I was curious about it.

I seriously doubt that this is the case. It would mess up the order of weeks in the show unless the elminate two people results show next week, in which case why send Michael home at all? Just keep him and let him perform and see how he fairs in the next weeks show.

I would be absolulely exstatic if Michael came back. This show is NOT going to be the same without him, I'm not even sure if I'm watching next week. But I can't get my hopes up to much I can't be to disappointed. And all the wishing in the world isn't going to bring him back, it's all in AI's hands now.

I really really smell something fishy about this show..I'm so sure that something *magical* happened as i said before our votes doesn't count. becacuse eveybody loves Michael. Micheal goes and Kristy stays? Big set up by the producers.. they want more show ratings by drawing attention by doing something unpredictable and unjust. And they want more people to vote as well ......TRICKY PERSONS!
....

----------------------awww, i feel the pain too, here it's 10:36 p.m. and I can't sleep..the fishy-thingy is in my head!! Cheer up...hu hu hu *sniff*


FLASH NEWS 3 SECONDS AGO!!!:

YAHOO RECAPS AND OTHER RECAPS SAID THAT NO ONE WILL BE ELIMINATED DUE TO IDOL GIVES BACK

...Questions about fake elimination is all over especially in yahoo answers...IS MY THEORY RIGHT? I'M NOT SHOCK IF MICHAEL WILL NEVER COMEBACK.......AT LEAST I TRY THIS!!ha ha you'll pay fox! PETITION: BRING MICHAEL BACK, APOLOGIZE RYAN-WORSE-THAN-SYMON!

I kept thinking that it was all just a joke, that any minute, they would say they were joking, but I think I'm sort of in shock! I wish he would come back!

If it were a scam, I don't think he'd be making the rounds on talk shows tonight, & this next upcoming week.
If it was a scam & just a fake elimination, they wouldn't have him going & trying to play it up & then fooling everyone.

So I'm pretty sure it WASN'T a fake elimination, so there really isn't a need to get your hopes up anymore.

We can all watch him on the talk shows & hear what he says about it all, & that's what matters. =]

You have a point but SCAMS are secrets and confedential..Just imagine when you were a child.. and you cheat in a test (I'm sure you done it even once).. YOU WILL NEVER SAY YOU CHEAT, EVEN NOW! IF I ASK YOU IF YOU CHEAT EVEN TWICE, YOU WILL SAY NO....even me.. If you are the scammer sure you'll act normal and do normal things so no one will suspect you...

I've always thought there was something fishy about voting/eliminations on AI. Stuff like this happens every year...and every year when a new contestant gets voted off that fanbase gets angry and vows to never watch the show again, petitions are made, and all that jazz but unfortunately it never does any good.


I agree...as much as I wish it were a "fake" elimination I'm pretty sure it wasn't...even though some of the "evidence" seems pretty convincing.

If that was a fake elimination, witch I don't believe, it would be really desrespectfull to michael [in case he doesn't know it] and to the fans. But, I'm pretty sure it wasn't a fake elimination. Too bad

To be honest, I've never cheated on a test in school, & I swear on the bible I never have. I'll admit it, I don't see the point in lying.

Thing is, they wouldn't make it nationwide like he was eliminated, & have him lie to people. It's just stupid on their part to have someone blatantly lie all over the place, on countless television shows, & even in interviews. I don't think Michael would be that cruel to lie to his fanbase or go with such a disgusting scheme like this. You could tell he was generally shocked on television, & there was no acting there.

Oh, how I wish Michael would come back. It's a longshot, but even if the opportunity arose, I don't think he would even take the offer. Best to just leave with grace and your dignity in tact.

Well, I'm not shock if Michael doesn't comeback. But I'm sure A.I made the *noise*....read Ramiele's blog...
ENDING: MICHAEL WILL NEVER COMEBACK BUT NEXT SEASON IT WILL HAPPEN THE *NOISE* AGAIN.

~I am a realist. It's unlikely that he'll come back on the show since it violates TV ethics and the whole voting system. If this was a perfect world, I'll hope that this was a complete and utter mistake. All we can do is hope for his success...
But then again,if there's a way to bring him back to the show, then why not?

im sorry guys, but hes not coming back..

i love michael just as much as everyone else, but come on.. theyre not gonna bring him back.